Closing Argument

Closing Argument

Alessandro Scire Calabrisotto

The Closing Argument cocktail is a contemporary take on the Last Word, featuring a refreshing and bold mix of mezcal, green Chartreuse, maraschino liqueur, and fresh lime juice. This modern classic balances smokiness, herbal complexity, and a hint of sweetness, making it an unforgettable drink for those who love bold, structured cocktails.

History of the Closing Argument Cocktail

The Closing Argument cocktail is a relatively new addition to the world of mixology, yet it carries the DNA of one of the most famous pre-Prohibition cocktails: The Last Word. The Last Word, first documented in Ted Saucier’s 1951 book Bottoms Up!, was a gin-based cocktail featuring equal parts gin, green Chartreuse, maraschino liqueur, and lime juice.

The Closing Argument emerged in the early 2010s during the craft cocktail renaissance. Bartenders looking to experiment with smoky, agave-based spirits began substituting gin with mezcal, a Mexican spirit known for its deep smokiness and earthy tones. The result was a drink that retained the complex, herbal, and citrus-forward nature of the Last Word but introduced a rich, smoky dimension.

While the origins of the Closing Argument aren’t as well documented as its predecessor, it quickly gained traction in high-end cocktail bars. The combination of mezcal’s smokiness, Chartreuse’s herbal depth, maraschino’s subtle cherry sweetness, and lime’s bright acidity makes this drink a perfect balance of old and new.

Recipe: How to Make a Closing Argument Cocktail

This drink follows the equal-parts structure that made the Last Word a classic, with a modern mezcal twist.

Ingredients:

  • 22.5 ml (0.75 oz) Mezcal

  • 22.5 ml (0.75 oz) Green Chartreuse

  • 22.5 ml (0.75 oz) Maraschino Liqueur

  • 22.5 ml (0.75 oz) Fresh Lime Juice

  • Garnish: Lime Wheel or Luxardo Cherry

Instructions:

  1. Combine Ingredients: Add the mezcal, green Chartreuse, maraschino liqueur, and lime juice to a cocktail shaker filled with ice.

  2. Shake: Shake vigorously for about 10–12 seconds until well-chilled.

  3. Strain: Double strain into a chilled coupe or Nick & Nora glass.

  4. Garnish: Express the oils from a lime twist over the drink or garnish with a Luxardo cherry for a classic touch.

Tips for Perfection:

  • Use a high-quality mezcal with a well-balanced smokiness, such as Del Maguey Vida or Montelobos.

  • Shake vigorously to ensure the lime juice integrates smoothly with the liqueurs.

  • Adjust the lime juice slightly if you prefer a sharper or softer acidity.

Additional Recommendations

Variations:

  • Tequila Argument: Replace mezcal with a reposado tequila for a smoother, less smoky version.

  • Golden Argument: Use yellow Chartreuse instead of green for a mellower, slightly sweeter take.

  • Spicy Argument: Muddle a slice of jalapeño before shaking for an added kick.

Pairings:

The Closing Argument’s smoky, citrus-forward profile pairs well with rich, savory dishes and light, acidic flavors. Try it with:

  • Grilled Tacos al Pastor: Complements the smoky and citrusy notes.

  • Aged Manchego or Cheddar: Enhances the herbal complexity of the Chartreuse.

  • Dark Chocolate with Sea Salt: Contrasts beautifully with the cocktail’s tartness and smokiness.

Presentation:

  • Serve in a chilled coupe glass to highlight its bold character.

  • Use a lime wheel or cherry as garnish for an elegant touch.

  • Double strain for a smooth, refined texture.

Curiosity: A Fun Fact About the Closing Argument Cocktail

Though inspired by the Last Word, the Closing Argument is often considered a more dramatic and intense version of its predecessor. The name itself hints at finality and conviction—perhaps a nod to its bold, smoky, and unforgettable finish.

Sources


Back to blog